High availability and load balancing of your Application Proxy connectors and applications
This article explains how traffic distribution works with your Application Proxy deployment. We'll discuss:
How traffic is distributed among users and connectors, along with tips for optimizing connector performance
How traffic flows between connectors and back-end app servers, with recommendations for load balancing among multiple back-end servers
Traffic distribution across connectors
Connectors establish their connections based on principles for high availability. There's no guarantee that traffic will always be evenly distributed across connectors and there is no session affinity. However, usage varies and requests are randomly sent to Application Proxy service instances. As a result, traffic is typically distributed almost evenly across the connectors. The diagram and steps below illustrate how connections are established between users and connectors.
- A user on a client device tries to access an on-premises application published through Application Proxy.
- The request goes through an Azure Load Balancer to determine which Application Proxy service instance should take the request. Per region, there are tens of instances available to accept the request. This method helps to evenly distribute the traffic across the service instances.
- The request is sent to Service Bus.
- Service Bus signals to an available connector. The connector then picks up the request from Service Bus.
- In step 2, requests go to different Application Proxy service instances, so connections are more likely to be made with different connectors. As a result, connectors are almost evenly used within the group.
- The connector passes the request to the application’s back-end server. Then the application sends the response back to the connector.
- The connector completes the response by opening an outbound connection to the service instance from where the request came. Then this connection is immediately closed. By default, each connector is limited to 200 concurrent outbound connections.
- The response is then passed back to the client from the service instance.
- Subsequent requests from the same connection repeat the steps above.
An application often has many resources and opens multiple connections when it's loaded. Each connection goes through the steps above to become allocated to a service instance, select a new available connector if the connection has not yet previously paired with a connector.
Best practices for high availability of connectors
Because of the way traffic is distributed among connectors for high availability, it's essential to always have at least two connectors in a connector group. Three connectors are preferred to provide additional buffer among connectors. To determine the correct number of connectors you needed, follow capacity planning documentation.
Place connectors on different outbound connections to avoid a single point of failure. If connectors use the same outbound connection, a network problem with the connection may impact all connectors using it.
Avoid forcing connectors to restart when connected to production applications. Doing so could negatively impact the distribution of traffic across connectors. Restarting connectors causes more connectors to be unavailable and forces connections to the remaining available connector. The result is an uneven use of the connectors initially.
Avoid all forms of inline inspection on outbound TLS communications between connectors and Azure. This type of inline inspection causes degradation to the communication flow.
Make sure to keep automatic updates running for your connectors. If the Application Proxy Connector Updater service is running, your connectors update automatically and receive the latest upgraded. If you don’t see the Connector Updater service on your server, you need to reinstall your connector to get any updates.
Traffic flow between connectors and back-end application servers
Another key area where high availability is a factor is the connection between connectors and the back-end servers. When an application is published through Azure AD Application Proxy, traffic from the users to the applications flows through three hops:
- The user connects to the Azure AD Application Proxy service public endpoint on Azure. The connection is established between the originating client IP address (public) of the client and the IP address of the Application Proxy endpoint.
- The Application Proxy connector pulls the HTTP request of the client from the Application Proxy Service.
- The Application Proxy connector connects to the target application. The connector uses its own IP address for establishing the connection.
X-Forwarded-For header field considerations
In some situations (like auditing, load balancing etc.), sharing the originating IP address of the external client with the on-premises environment is a requirement. To address the requirement, Azure AD Application Proxy connector adds the X-Forwarded-For header field with the originating client IP address (public) to the HTTP request. The appropriate network device (load balancer, firewall) or the web server or back-end application can then read and use the information.
Best practices for load balancing among multiple app servers
When the connector group that's assigned to the Application Proxy application has two or more connectors, and you’re running the back-end web application on multiple servers (server farm), a good load-balancing strategy is required. A good strategy ensures that servers pick up client requests evenly and prevents over- or under-utilization of servers in the server farm.
Scenario 1: Back-end application does not require session persistence
The simplest scenario is where the back-end web application doesn’t require session stickiness (session persistence). Any request from the user can be handled by any back-end application instance in the server farm. You can use a layer 4 load balancer and configure it with no affinity. Some options include Microsoft Network Load Balancing and Azure Load Balancer or a load balancer from another vendor. Alternatively, round-robin DNS can be configured.
Scenario 2: Back-end application requires session persistence
In this scenario, the back-end web application requires session stickiness (session persistence) during the authenticated session. All requests from the user must be handled by the back-end application instance that runs on the same server in the server farm. This scenario can be more complicated because the client usually establishes multiple connections to the Application Proxy service. Requests over different connections might arrive at different connectors and servers in the farm. Because each connector uses its own IP address for this communication, the load balancer can't ensure session stickiness based on the IP address of the connectors. Source IP Affinity can't be used either. Here are some options for scenario 2:
Option 1: Base the session persistence on a session cookie set by the load balancer. This option is recommended because it allows the load to be spread more evenly among the back-end servers. It requires a layer 7 load balancer with this capability and that can handle the HTTP traffic and terminate the TLS connection. You can use Azure Application Gateway (Session Affinity) or a load balancer from another vendor.
Option 2: Base the session persistence on the X-Forwarded-For header field. This option requires a layer 7 load balancer with this capability and that can handle the HTTP traffic and terminate the TLS connection.
Option 3: Configure the back-end application to not require session persistence.
Refer to your software vendor's documentation to understand the load-balancing requirements of the back-end application.