Migrating from DNX to .NET Core CLI (project.json)


The RC1 release of .NET Core and ASP.NET Core 1.0 introduced DNX tooling. The RC2 release of .NET Core and ASP.NET Core 1.0 moved from DNX to the .NET Core CLI.

As a slight refresher, let's recap what DNX was about. DNX was a runtime and a toolset used to build .NET Core and, more specifically, ASP.NET Core 1.0 applications. It consisted of 3 main pieces:

  1. DNVM - an install script for obtaining DNX
  2. DNX (Dotnet Execution Runtime) - the runtime that executes your code
  3. DNU (Dotnet Developer Utility) - tooling for managing dependencies, building and publishing your applications

With the introduction of the CLI, all of the above are now part of a single toolset. However, since DNX was available in RC1 timeframe, you might have projects that were built using it that you would want to move off to the new CLI tooling.

This migration guide will cover the essentials on how to migrate projects off of DNX and onto .NET Core CLI. If you are just starting a project on .NET Core from scratch, you can freely skip this document.

Main changes in the tooling

There are some general changes in the tooling that should be outlined first.

No more DNVM

DNVM, short for DotNet Version Manager was a bash/PowerShell script used to install a DNX on your machine. It helped users get the DNX they need from the feed they specified (or default ones) as well as mark a certain DNX "active", which would put it on the $PATH for the given session. This would allow you to use the various tools.

DNVM was discontinued because its feature set was made redundant by changes coming in the .NET Core CLI.

The CLI comes packaged in two main ways:

  1. Native installers for a given platform
  2. Install script for other situations (like CI servers)

Given this, the DNVM install features are not needed. But what about the runtime selection features?

You reference a runtime in your project.json by adding a package of a certain version to your dependencies. With this change, your application will be able to use the new runtime bits. Getting these bits to your machine is the same as with the CLI: you install the runtime via one of the native installers it supports or via its install script.

Different commands

If you were using DNX, you used some commands from one of its three parts (DNX, DNU or DNVM). With the CLI, some of these commands change, some are not available and some are the same but have slightly different semantics.

The table below shows the mapping between the DNX/DNU commands and their CLI counterparts.

DNX command CLI command Description
dnx run dotnet run Run code from source.
dnu build dotnet build Build an IL binary of your code.
dnu pack dotnet pack Package up a NuGet package of your code.
dnx [command] (for example, "dnx web") N/A* In DNX world, run a command as defined in the project.json.
dnu install N/A* In the DNX world, install a package as a dependency.
dnu restore dotnet restore Restore dependencies specified in your project.json. (see note)
dnu publish dotnet publish Publish your application for deployment in one of the three forms (portable, portable with native and standalone).
dnu wrap N/A* In DNX world, wrap a project.json in csproj.
dnu commands N/A* In DNX world, manage the globally installed commands.

(*) - these features are not supported in the CLI by design.

DNX features that are not supported

As the table above shows, there are features from the DNX world that we decided not to support in the CLI, at least for the time being. This section will go through the most important ones and outline the rationale behind not supporting them as well as workarounds if you do need them.

Global commands

DNU came with a concept called "global commands". These were, essentially, console applications packaged up as NuGet packages with a shell script that would invoke the DNX you specified to run the application.

The CLI does not support this concept. It does, however, support the concept of adding per-project commands that can be invoked using the familiar dotnet <command> syntax.

Installing dependencies

As of v1, the .NET Core CLI doesn't have an install command for installing dependencies. In order to install a package from NuGet, you would need to add it as a dependency to your project.json file and then run dotnet restore (see note).

Running your code

There are two main ways to run your code. One is from source, with dotnet run. Unlike dnx run, this will not do any in-memory compilation. It will actually invoke dotnet build to build your code and then run the built binary.

Another way is using the dotnet itself to run your code. This is done by providing a path to your assembly: dotnet path/to/an/assembly.dll.

Migrating your DNX project to .NET Core CLI

In addition to using new commands when working with your code, there are three major things left in migrating from DNX:

  1. Migrate the global.json file if you have it to be able to use CLI.
  2. Migrating the project file (project.json) itself to the CLI tooling.
  3. Migrating off of any DNX APIs to their BCL counterparts.

Changing the global.json file

The global.json file acts like a solution file for both the RC1 and RC2 (or later) projects. In order for the .NET Core CLI (as well as Visual Studio) to differentiate between RC1 and later versions, they use the "sdk": { "version" } property to make the distinction which project is RC1 or later. If global.json doesn't have this node at all, it is assumed to be the latest.

In order to update the global.json file, either remove the property or set it to the exact version of the tools that you wish to use, in this case 1.0.0-preview2-003121:

    "sdk": {
        "version": "1.0.0-preview2-003121"

Migrating the project file

The CLI and DNX both use the same basic project system based on project.json file. The syntax and the semantics of the project file are pretty much the same, with small differences based on the scenarios. There are also some changes to the schema which you can see in the schema file.

If you are building a console application, you need to add the following snippet to your project file:

"buildOptions": {
    "emitEntryPoint": true

This instructs dotnet build to emit an entry point for your application, effectively making your code runnable. If you are building a class library, simply omit the above section. Of course, once you add the above snippet to your project.json file, you need to add a static entry point. With the move off DNX, the DI services it provided are no longer available and thus this needs to be a basic .NET entry point: static void Main().

If you have a "commands" section in your project.json, you can remove it. Some of the commands that used to exist as DNU commands, such as Entity Framework CLI commands, are being ported to be per-project extensions to the CLI. If you built your own commands that you are using in your projects, you need to replace them with CLI extensions. In this case, the commands node in project.json needs to be replaced by the tools node and it needs to list the tools dependencies.

After these things are done, you need to decide which type of portability you wish for you app. With .NET Core, we have invested into providing a spectrum of portability options that you can choose from. For instance, you may want to have a fully portable application or you may want to have a self-contained application. The portable application option is more like .NET Framework applications work: it needs a shared component to execute it on the target machine (.NET Core). The self-contained application doesn't require .NET Core to be installed on the target, but you have to produce one application for each OS you wish to support. These portability types and more are discussed in the application portability type document.

Once you make a call on what type of portability you want, you need to change your targeted framework(s). If you were writing applications for .NET Core, you were most likely using dnxcore50 as your targeted framework. With the CLI and the changes that the new .NET Standard brought, the framework needs to be one of the following:

  1. netcoreapp1.0 - if you are writing applications on .NET Core (including ASP.NET Core applications)
  2. netstandard1.6 - if you are writing class libraries for .NET Core

If you are using other dnx targets, like dnx451 you will need to change those as well. dnx451 should be changed to net451. Please refer to the .NET Standard topic for more information.

Your project.json is now mostly ready. You need to go through your dependencies list and update the dependencies to their newer versions, especially if you are using ASP.NET Core dependencies. If you were using separate packages for BCL APIs, you can use the runtime package as explained in the application portability type document.

Once you are ready, you can try restoring with dotnet restore (see note). Depending on the version of your dependencies, you may encounter errors if NuGet cannot resolve the dependencies for one of the targeted frameworks above. This is a "point-in-time" problem; as time progresses, more and more packages will include support for these frameworks. For now, if you run into this, you can use the imports statement within the framework node to specify to NuGet that it can restore the packages targeting the framework within the "imports" statement. The restoring errors you get in this case should provide enough information to tell you which frameworks you need to import. If you are slightly lost or new to this, in general, specifying dnxcore50 and portable-net45+win8 in the imports statement should do the trick. The JSON snippet below shows how this looks like:

    "frameworks": {
        "netcoreapp1.0": {
            "imports": ["dnxcore50", "portable-net45+win8"]

Running dotnet build will show any eventual build errors, though there shouldn't be too many of them. After your code is building and running properly, you can test it out with the runner. Execute dotnet <path-to-your-assembly> and see it run.

You don't have to run dotnet restore because it's run implicitly by all commands that require a restore to occur, such as dotnet new, dotnet build, dotnet run, dotnet test, dotnet publish, and dotnet pack. To disable implicit restore, use the --no-restore option.

The dotnet restore command is still useful in certain scenarios where explicitly restoring makes sense, such as continuous integration builds in Azure DevOps Services or in build systems that need to explicitly control when the restore occurs.

For information about how to manage NuGet feeds, see the dotnet restore documentation.