FAQs for continuous testing

Visual Studio 2017 | Visual Studio 2015 | VSTS | TFS 2017 | TFS 2015

General topics

Q: How do I run tests from different unit test frameworks with my build?

A: First, set up your test frameworks in your development tool. For example, in Visual Studio:

  1. Set up the plug-in for your test framework, if you haven't already.

  2. Create a folder that has the custom binaries for your plug-in. (The plug-in package for your framework is a .vsix file. Change the extension to .zip so that you can unzip it.)

  3. Add these assemblies to version control and let the build controller know where to get them.

  4. In your build definition, provide the path to the test framework in the Path to Custom Test Adapters* parameter:

    Build def, VSTest task, custom test framework

Q: I'm having problems using xUnit with .NET Core apps. Where can I get more information?

A: See the blog post Unit Tests with .NET Core and VSTS.

Q: What are the typical types of tests I can run to validate my app and deployment?

A: Testing in a continuous integration and continuous deployment (CI/CD) scenario typically consists of:

  1. Run unit tests in the CI pipeline, as demonstrated in the example above. The Visual Studio Test task automatically runs tests included in the app assemblies, but there is a wide range of configuration options you can specify, such as running only specific tests. See Run Tests using Visual Studio task.

  2. Run functional tests in the early stages of the CD pipeline. These are typically Selenium (for web apps) and Coded UI tests. To do this, add the Deploy Test Agent and Run Functional Tests tasks to your release definition. See Testing in Continuous Integration and Continuous Deployment Workflows.

  3. Run load tests after the app is deployed to staging and production, after it passes all functional tests. The example shown above is just a simple test that accesses a single page in the web app to validate that deployment succeeded and the app is running successfully. You can perform must more comprehensive load testing to validate the entire app by running cloud-based load tests and Apache JMeter load tests.

Q: Can I find a specific test run?

A: Yes, type the Run ID into the search box in the left column:

Find test run

Q: Can I find specific results from a test run?

A: Yes, after you find your test run, create a query in the Filter tab to find the test results you want:

Find specific test results

Q: Can I deploy to a staging slot first, and then to production?

A: Yes, you can create additional deployment slots in Azure Web Apps, and specify which slot to deploy your app to. If you do not specify a slot, the default Production slot is used. After you deploy, you can swap an app to a different slot using the Azure App Service Manage task. See Swap deployment slots.

You can use task phases and the Manual Intervention task in your release definition to pause a deployment; for example, to examine test results after the load tests have run and before the app is swapped from staging to production.

Q: Where can I find details about configuring test agents?

A: See Install and configure test agents

Q: What if I want to run debug builds of native (.cpp) unit tests on the machine with the test agent?

A: Make sure that you have debug versions of the Universal C Runtime (UCRT) on the machine with the test agent, specifically these libraries: ucrtbased.dll and vcruntime140d.dll. You can include these items with your deployment. If you're running release builds of .cpp unit tests, make sure that you have Windows Update KB2999226 on your test agent machine.

Q: Where can I learn more about integrating tests with my build?

A: Try these blog posts and videos:


Associating tests with test cases

Q: What are the differences if I am still using a XAML build?

A: If you are using a XAML build in VSTS or TFS, you can run tests that you have associated in a Build-Deploy-Test workflow using a Lab environment. You can also run tests using Microsoft Test Manager (MTM) and a Lab environment.

Q: What types of tests are supported?

A: These are the limitations for each type of test:

  • Coded UI test, Selenium tests, and unit tests written using Version 1 of the MSTest framework can be associated with a test case.
  • Unit tests that use the.NET Core framework cannot be associated with a test case.
  • Tests that use other test frameworks such as Version 2 of the MSTest framework, xUnit, nUnit, Chutzpah, and others cannot be associated with a test case.
  • Associating ordered tests and generic tests may work, but running these tests is not supported.

Q: Can I configure work items to open in Visual Studio?

A: Yes, if you want test work items to open inside Visual Studio instead of the default VSTS or TFS UI in your web browser, change the Work Items | General setting from the Tools | Options menu in Visual Studio.

Change work item display mode


Running automated tests from the Test hub

Q: Can I override the build or environment set at the test plan level for a specific instance of test run?

A: Yes, you can do this using the Run with options command. Open the shortcut menu for the test suite in the left column and choose Run with options.

Configuring the Run with options dialog

Enter the following values in the Run with options dialog and then choose OK:

  • Test type and runner: Select Automated tests using Release environment.

  • Build: Select the build that has the test binaries. The test results will be associated this build.

  • Release Definition: Select a definition from the list of release definitions that can consume the selected build artifact.

  • Release Environment: Select the name of the environment configured in your release definition.

Configuring the Run with options dialog

Q: Why use release environments to run tests?

A: Release Management offers a compelling orchestration workflow to obtain test binaries as artifacts and run tests. This workflow shares the same concepts used in the scheduled testing workflow, meaning users running tests in scheduled workflow will find it easy to adapt; for example, by cloning an existing scheduled testing release definition.

Another major benefit is the availability of a rich set of tasks in the task catalog that enable a range of activates to be performed before and after running tests. Examples include preparing and cleaning test data, creating and cleaning configuration files, and more.

Q: How does selecting "Test run" in the Visual Studio Test task version 2 work?

A: The Test management sub-system uses the test run object to pass the list of tests selected for execution. The test task looks up the test run identifier, extracts the test execution information such as the container and test method names, runs the tests, updates the test run results, and sets the test points associated with the test results in the test run. From an auditing perspective, the Visual Studio task provides a trace from the historical releases and the test run identifiers to the tests that were submitted for on-demand test execution.

Q: Should the agent run in interactive mode or as a service?

A: If you are running UI tests such as coded UI or Selenium tests, the agent on the test machines must be running in interactive mode, not as a service, to allow the agent to launch a web browser. If you are using a headless browser such as PhantomJS, the agent can be run as a service or in interactive mode. See Build and Release Agents, Deploy an agent on Windows, and Agent pools and queues.

Q: Where can I find detailed documentation on how to run Selenium tests?

A: See Get started with Selenium testing.

Q: What happens if I select multiple configurations for the same test?

A: Currently, the on-demand workflow is not configuration-aware. In future releases, we plan to pass configuration context to the test method and report the appropriate results.

Q: What if I need to download product binaries and test binaries from different builds? Or if I need to obtain artifacts from a source such as Jenkins?

A: The current capability is optimized for a single team build to be tested on-demand using a Release Management workflow. We will evaluate support for multi-artifact releases, including non-Team Build artifacts such as Jenkins, based on user feedback.

Q: I already have a scheduled testing release definition. Can I reuse the same definition to run test on-demand, or should I create a new definition as shown above?

A: We recommend you use a separate release definition and environment for on-demand automated testing from the Test hub because:

  • You may not want to deploy the app every time you want to run a few on-demand tests. Scheduled testing environments are typically set up to deploy the product and then run tests.

  • New releases are triggered for every on-demand run. If you have many testers executing a few on-demand test runs every day, your scheduled testing release definition could be overloaded with releases for these runs, making it difficult to find releases that were triggered for the pipeline that contains scheduled testing and deployment to production.

  • You may want to configure the Visual Studio Test task with a Test run identifier as an input so that you can trace what triggered the release. See How does selecting "Test run (for on-demand runs)" in the Visual Studio Test task work?.

Q: Can I trigger these runs and view the results in Microsoft Test Manager?

A: No. MTM will not support running automated tests against Team Foundation builds. It only works in the web-based interface for VSTS and TFS. All new manual and automated testing product development investments will be in the web-based interface. No further development is planned for MTM. See Guidance on Microsoft Test Manager usage.

Q: I have multiple testers in my team. Can they run tests from different test suites or test plans in parallel using the same release definition?

A: They can use the same release definition to trigger multiple test runs in parallel if:

  • The agent pool associated with the environment has sufficient agents to cater for parallel requests. If sufficient agents are not available, runs can still be triggered but releases will be queued for processing until agents are available.

  • You have sufficient concurrent pipelines to enable concurrent releases. See Concurrent pipelines in VSTS or Concurrent pipelines in TFS for more information.

  • Testers do not run the same tests in parallel. Doing so may cause results to be overwritten depending on the order of execution.

To enable multiple different test runs to execute in parallel, set the Release Management environment trigger option for behavior when multiple releases are waiting to be deployed as follows:

  • If your application supports tests running in parallel from different sources, set this option to Allow multiple releases to be deployed at the same time.

  • If your application does not support tests running in parallel from different sources, set this option to Allow only one active deployment at a time.

Q: What are the typical error scenarios or issues I should look out for if my tests don't run?

A: Check and resolve issues as follows:

  • The release definition and environment in which I want to run tests are not shown after I select the build.

    • Make sure the build definition that is generating the build is linked as the primary artifact in the Artifacts tab of the release definition.

  • I get an error that I don't have sufficient permission to trigger a release.

    • Configure Create releases and Manage deployments permissions for the user in the Security menu of the release definition. See Release permissions.

  • I get an error that no automated tests were found.

    • Check the automation status of the selected tests. Do this in the work item for the test case, or use the Column options link in the Test Plans page of the Test hub to add the Automation status column to the list of tests. See the pre-requisites section for information about automating manual tests.

  • My tests didn't execute, and I suspect the release definition is incorrect.

    • Use the link in the Run summary page to access the release instance used to run the tests, and view the release logs.

  • My tests go into the error state, or remain "in-progress" even after release to the environment is triggered.

    • Check if the release environment that you selected has the correct task and version selected. You must use version 2 or higher of the Visual Studio Test task. Version 1 of the task, and the Run Functional Tests task, are not supported.