Eye tracking on HoloLens 2
HoloLens 2 allows for a new level of context and human understanding within the holographic experience by providing developers with the ability to use information about what the user is looking at. This page explains how developers can benefit from eye tracking for various use cases, and what to look for when designing eye-gaze-based user interactions.
Eye tracking API has been designed with a user’s privacy in mind, avoiding passing any identifiable information, particularly any biometrics. For eye-tracking capable applications, the user needs to grant app permission to use eye tracking information.
|Feature||HoloLens (1st gen)||HoloLens 2||Immersive headsets|
For eye tracking to work accurately, each user is required to go through an eye tracking user calibration for which the user has to look at a set of holographic targets. This allows the device to adjust the system for a more comfortable and higher quality viewing experience for the user and to ensure accurate eye tracking at the same time.
Eye tracking should work for most users, but there are rare cases in which a user can't calibrate successfully. Calibration might fail for various reasons, including but not limited to:
- The user previously opted out of the calibration process
- The user got distracted and didn't follow the calibration targets
- The user has certain types of contact lenses and glasses, which the system doesn't yet support
- The user has certain eye physiology, eye conditions or had eye surgery, which the system doesn't yet support
- External factors inhibiting reliable eye tracking such as smudges on the HoloLens visor or eyeglasses, intense direct sunlight, and occlusions due to hair in front of the eyes
Developers should make sure to provide adequate support for users for whom eye tracking data may not be available (who aren't able to calibrate successfully). We have provided recommendations for fallback solutions in the section at the bottom of this page.
To learn more about the calibration and about how to ensure a smooth experience, check our eye tracking user calibration page.
Available eye tracking data
Before going into detail about specific use cases for eye-gaze input, we want to briefly point out the capabilities that the HoloLens 2 Eye Tracking API provides. Developers get access to a single eye-gaze ray (gaze origin and direction) at approximately 30 FPS (30 Hz). For more detailed information about how to access eye tracking data, refer to our developer guides for using eye-gaze in DirectX and eye-gaze in Unity.
The predicted eye-gaze is approximately within 1.5 degrees in visual angle around the actual target (see the illustration below). As slight imprecisions are expected, developers should plan for some margin around this lower-bound value (for example, 2.0-3.0 degrees may result in a much more comfortable experience). We'll discuss how to address the selection of small targets in more detail below. For eye tracking to work accurately, each user is required to go through an eye tracking user calibration.
Optimal target size at a 2-meter distance
Eye tracking enables applications to track where the user is looking in real time. The following use cases describe some interactions that are possible with eye tracking on HoloLens 2 in mixed reality. These use cases aren't yet part of the Holographic Shell experience (that is, the interface that you see when you start up your HoloLens 2). You can try some of them in the Mixed Reality Toolkit, which provides several interesting and powerful examples for using eye tracking, such as quick and effortless eye-supported target selections, and automatically scrolling through text based on what the user looks at.
Information about where and what a user looks at provides a powerful context for other inputs, such as voice, hands, and controllers. This can be used for various tasks. For example, this can range from quickly and effortlessly targeting across the scene by looking at a hologram and saying "select" (also see gaze and commit) or "put this...", then looking over to where the user wants to place the hologram and say "...there". Examples for this can be found in Mixed Reality Toolkit - Eye-supported Target Selection and Mixed Reality Toolkit - Eye-supported Target Positioning.
Additionally, an example for user intent might include using information about what users look at to enhance engagement with embodied virtual agents and interactive holograms. For instance, virtual agents might adapt available options and their behavior, based on currently viewed content.
The category of implicit actions closely relates to user intent.
The idea is that holograms or user interface elements react in an instinctual way that may not even feel like the user is interacting with the system at all, but rather that the system and the user are in sync.
One example is eye-gaze-based auto scroll where the user can read a long text, which automatically starts scrolling once the user gets to the bottom of the textbox to keep the user in the flow of reading, without lifting a finger.
A key aspect of this is that the scrolling speed adapts to the reading speed of the user. Another example is eye-supported zoom and pan where the user can feel like diving exactly toward what he or she's focused on. Triggering and controlling zoom speed can be controlled by voice or hand input, which is important for providing the user with the feeling of control while avoiding being overwhelmed. We'll talk about these design considerations in more detail below. Once zoomed in, the user can smoothly follow, for example, the course of a street to explore his or her neighborhood by using their eye-gaze. Demo examples for these types of interactions can be found in the Mixed Reality Toolkit - Eye-supported Navigation sample.
Other use cases for implicit actions may include:
- Smart notifications: Ever get annoyed by notifications popping up right where you're looking? Taking into account what a user is paying attention to, you can make this experience better by offsetting notifications from where the user is currently gazing. This limits distractions and automatically dismisses them once the user is finished reading.
- Attentive holograms: Holograms that subtly react when being gazed upon. This can range from slightly glowing UI elements, a slowly blooming flower to a virtual dog starting to look back at the user and wagging its tail. This interaction might provide an interesting sense of connectivity and satisfaction in your application.
Information on where or what users look at can be an immensely powerful tool. It can help assess usability of designs and identify problems in workflows to make them more efficient. Eye tracking visualization and analytics are a common practice in various application areas. With HoloLens 2, we provide a new dimension to this understanding as 3D holograms can be placed in real-world contexts and assessed accordingly. The Mixed Reality Toolkit provides basic examples for logging and loading eye tracking data and how to visualize them. Microsoft is dedicated to facilitating innovation while ensuring that users have an informed and transparent experience with how their eye tracking information is used. We'll work with our developers and UX teams to provide guidance for third parties to ensure that experiences are centered around the user.
Other applications in this area may include:
- Remote eye-gaze visualization: Remote eye-gaze visualizations: Visualize what remote collaborators are looking at, to be able to provide immediate feedback and facilitate more accurate information processing.
- User research studies: Attention tracking can help researchers get more insights into how users perceive and engage with the natural environment, without interfering, to design more instinctual human-computer-interactions. Eye tracking can provide information that is not directly articulated by participants in the study, which otherwise might be easily missed by the researcher.
- Training and performance monitoring: Practice and optimize the execution of tasks by identifying bottlenecks more effectively in the execution flow. Eye tracking can provide natural, real-time, and objective information to help improve training, productivity, and safety in the workplace.
- Design evaluations, marketing, and consumer research: Eye tracking enables commercial companies to perform marketing and consumer studies in real-world environments or analyze what captures a user’s attention to improve product or space design.
Other use cases
Gaming: Ever wanted to have superpowers? Here's your chance! You can levitate holograms by staring at them. Shoot laser beams from your eyes - try it out in RoboRaid for HoloLens 2. Turn enemies into stone or freeze them. Use your x-ray vision to explore buildings. Your imagination is the limit! Beware of not overwhelming the user though - to find out more, check out our eye-gaze-based input design guidelines.
Expressive avatars: Eye tracking aids in more expressive 3D avatars by using live eye tracking data to animate the avatar's eyes that indicate what the user is looking at.
Text entry: Eye tracking can be used as an alternative for low-effort text entry, especially when speech or hands are inconvenient to use.
Using eye-gaze for interaction
Building an interaction that takes advantage of fast-moving eye targeting can be challenging. On the one hand, the eyes move so fast that you need to be careful on how to use eye-gaze input, because otherwise users may find the experience overwhelming or distracting. On the other hand, you can also create truly magical experiences that will excite your users! To help you, check out our overview of key advantages, challenges, and design recommendations for eye-gaze for interaction.
Fallback solutions when eye tracking isn't available
In rare cases, eye tracking data might not be available. This can be because of different reasons from which the most common are listed below:
- The system failed to calibrate the user.
- The user skipped the calibration.
- The user is calibrated, but decided to not give permission to your app to use their eye tracking data.
- The user has unique eyeglasses or some eye condition that the system doesn't yet support.
- External factors inhibiting reliable eye tracking such as smudges on the HoloLens visor or eyeglasses, intense direct sunlight, and occlusions because of hair in front of the eyes.
Developers should ensure that there's appropriate fallback support for these users. On the Eye Tracking in DirectX page, we explain the APIs required to detect whether eye tracking data is available.
While some users may have consciously decided to revoke, access to their eye tracking data and are ok with the trade-off of an inferior user experience to the privacy of not providing access to their eye tracking data, in some cases this may be unintentional. If your app uses eye tracking, and this is an important part of the experience, we recommend clearly communicating this to the user.
Kindly informing the user why eye tracking is critical for your application (maybe even listing some enhanced features) to experience the full potential of your application, can help the user to better understand what they're giving up. Help the user identify why eye tracking may not be working (based on the above checks) and offer some suggestions to quickly troubleshoot potential issues.
For example, if you can detect that the system supports eye tracking, the user is calibrated and has even given their permission, yet no eye tracking data is received, then this may point to some other issues such as smudges or the eyes being occluded.
There are rare cases of users for whom eye tracking may not work. Hence, please be respectful of that by allowing to dismiss or even disable reminders for enabling eye tracking in your app.
Fall back for apps using eye-gaze as a primary input pointer
If your app uses eye-gaze as a pointer input to quickly select holograms across the scene, yet eye tracking data is unavailable, we recommend falling back to head-gaze and start showing the head-gaze cursor. We recommend using a timeout (for example, 500–1500 ms) to determine whether to switch or not. This action prevents cursors from appearing every time the system may briefly lose tracking because of fast eye motions or winks and blinks. If you're a Unity developer, the automatic fallback to head-gaze is already handled in the Mixed Reality Toolkit. If you're a DirectX developer, you need to handle this switch yourself.
Fall back for other eye-tracking-specific applications
Your app may use eye-gaze in a unique way that is tailored specifically to the eyes. For example, animating an avatar’s eyes or for eye-based attention heatmaps relying on precise information about visual attention. In this case, there's no clear fallback. If eye tracking isn't available, these capabilities may need to be disabled. Again, we recommend to clearly communicate this to the user who may be unaware that the capability isn't working.
This page has hopefully provided you with a good overview to get you started understanding the role of eye tracking and eye-gaze input for HoloLens 2. To get started developing, check out our information on the role of eye-gaze for interacting with holograms, eye-gaze in Unity and eye-gaze in DirectX.