Having to now to recreate MFA settings for 40+ accounts because of this laziness.
Lesson learned, do not use Microsoft Authenticator for TOTP codes.
When setting up MFA, best option seems to be to use more user friendly software like Bitwarden and store the TOTP codes in there. And then if you need Microsoft Authenticator features, then you can use the same TOTP code in authenticator.
This way when Authenticator shows you what a pile of trash it is, you can use the TOTP codes you saved in Bitwarden to re-create any accounts. Or just continue to use Bitwarden if all you need are one-time codes.
Get it together Microsoft.