IE and the Accept Header
RFC 2616 describes the Accept request header as follows:
The Accept request-header field can be used to specify certain media types which are acceptable for the response. Accept headers can be used to indicate that the request is specifically limited to a small set of desired types, as in the case of a request for an in-line image.
While I’ll spare you a debate about the merits and pitfalls of server-driven content negotiation, suffice it to say that I think that such negotiation is impractical (and/or suboptimal) for most scenarios encountered by general-purpose web browsers. The primary reason to spare the debate (and inevitable flame war) is that it’s mostly a moot point, because all versions of Internet Explorer are seriously limited when it comes to support of the Accept header. Note: other browsers actually suffer from similar limitations in certain cases– I’m focused on IE in this post because it’s the browser I work on.
Let’s take a look what IE sends in the Accept header.
Install a recent version of Fiddler, run it, and click Rules > Customize Rules. Scroll to the static function Main() block, and add the following line within:
FiddlerObject.UI.lvSessions.AddBoundColumn("Accept", 50, "@request.Accept");
Save the file, and you’ll see a new column titled Accept appears within the Fiddler UI, showing the value of the Accept request header.
Navigate to websites, and watch the value of the Accept header sent in each request. You’ll quickly notice that in almost all cases, the Accept header contains */* , meaning that IE is willing to accept documents of any MIME type. This is technically accurate, insofar as IE will offer to download and save MIME-types it doesn’t know how to render.
However, in some navigations, you’ll see that IE sends a more complete string, containing a wide variety of MIME-types. For instance:
image/jpeg, application/x-ms-application, image/gif, application/xaml+xml, image/pjpeg, application/x-ms-xbap, application/msword, application/vnd.ms-excel, application/x-shockwave-flash, */*
Hit F5 to refresh that page, and IE will probably go back to sending */* again. Clearly, IE is inconsistent in what it chooses to send in the Accept header, but by now you’re probably curious where these MIME types even come from.
IE generates this list by enumerating the values listed in the following registry key:
HKLM\Software\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Internet Settings\Accepted Documents
Any application can, upon install, attempt to advertise the MIME-types it supports using this registry key. However, I strongly recommend that developers not list MIME types here.
Why not? Well, first of all, the list isn’t typically sent, so you cannot write server code which checks for your MIME-type and conditionally serves content of that type only if the client asks for it. In almost all cases, servers will end up getting requests for content of type */* and return content in your format anyway.
More importantly, it turns out that Accept headers containing custom types cause two serious problems:
- Slower performance due to bloated requests
- Server errors on sites expecting headers of fixed maximum length
The first problem is pretty obvious: any time the full MIME-type list is sent, significant request bandwidth is wasted. The Accept header above, for instance, is 191 characters long, and due to the asymmetrical nature of bandwidth for most users (upload bandwidth is usually a small fraction of download bandwidth) such waste can quickly add up.
The second problem is less obvious but more serious: Many web server devices and frameworks expect HTTP headers to be shorter than a certain length and will return HTTP error codes (HTTP/400 and HTTP/406 are popular) if overlong headers are received. Beyond the immediate annoyance of such errors, there’s almost never any indication to the user what has gone wrong and how to fix it. Users cannot be expected to know that the problem is an overlong header and find the above-mentioned registry key to start deleting entries.
Often, an IE user encountering this problem will try another browser and find that it works fine, because other browsers generate their Accept headers from other lists that are less likely to be updated by installed applications. For instance, Firefox sends the value of its network.http.accept.default preference as the content of the Accept header.
Alert readers will notice that Microsoft applications are culprits in Accept header bloat, and this is something that IE will be working with other teams around the company to help mitigate. In a future IE version, we may remove or substantially change Accept-header generation logic to help eliminate this problem.
User-Agent string extensibility causes a similar problem, and that issue is so prevalent that it will be the subject of a future post: Internet Explorer User-Agent: Use and Abuse.
Thanks for reading!
Update: The IE9 Release Candidate significantly changes IE's use of the Accept header in IE9 Browser Mode. IE9 deprecates registry-based extensibility of the Accept header, and rather than sending */* for most downloads, now sends a more-specific Accept header based on which HTML element initiated the request. I wrote about the details of IE9 Accept Headers on the Fiddler Blog.